Ex-S&WB leader disputes firing over pay raise
By Dennis Woltering
December 3, 2018
NEW ORLEANS — Tensions were already running high in mid-August when the New Orleans Sewerage and Water Board resumed shutting off water service to some customers who had not paid their bills. The Board indicated it had no choice since it was running low on finances to keep the system operating.
One water service customer, Shirley Landrum, said “My gut feeling is it’s not right.”
Then, came news that hit like a bombshell. Three members of the top brass had just been given big raises.
“This is lunacy,” said Pat Bryant, another water service customer.
$20,000 hikes for both Ronald Doucette, the head of security, and Valerie Rivers, who was in charge of logistics, boosted annual pay for each to $150,000. A $45,000 raise for Sharon Judkins, the head of Human Resources, boosted her annual pay to $175,000.
Then word of the pay hikes became public.
That is when Judkins said “The then-executive director had been directed to ask for my resignation.”
The raises were retroactive to the first of the year, giving Judkins backpay of $22,500.
She says she was “forced to resign. Actually coerced into resigning.”
Mayor LaToya Cantrell forced out all three as well as executive director Jade Brown-Russell, who approved the raises.
But Judkins argues the raises were justified based on a job compensation and classification study that had taken more than a year to complete.
“The board (of directors) was very aware of the class-comp study,” she said. “They actually sanctioned the study. They were given updates on a frequent basis about the class-comp study.”
She says employees throughout the system were given raises the study recommended — some as high as 26 percent. Judkins says she and the two other leaders were just among the last to get raises.
But, at a September breakfast briefing event sponsored by the Bureau of Governmental Research, Cantrell said the new compensation recommendations were for civil service workers like pump operators and welders, people she said “who make the Sewerage and Water Board run. It did not have much to do with these employees who were non-classified employees.”
But Sharon Judkins disputes that. She said as the study clearly shows, the analysis addressed every position in the organization and recommended salary adjustments for top brass as well as civil service workers.
She says the agency hired the new Chief Financial Officer, Yvette Downs, in June at the recommended level of $175,000.
What’s more, when hired more than two years ago, she says she and the other two deputy directors were promised they would get significant raises when the compensation study was completed.
“I was told, first of all, immediately as we negotiated me coming to New Orleans, your salary is very low at this time, but I promise you, your salary will be increased,” Judkins said.
Mayor Cantrell does not deny that.
“What I was told,” she said, “was that those raises were aligned with promises that were made by the previous director of the Sewerage and Water Board.”
Sharon Judkins complains she was denied due process. And she alleges that Mayor Cantrell violated the open meetings law in a reported conference call about the pay raises with board members without public notice or participation before Judkins and the two other deputy directors were terminated.
“I could not be present at that meeting to hear what the board discussed about the position in which I held. I could not be present to give any insight from my perspective on what happened,” Judkins said. “Yeah my rights were violated as an employee of being present at a meeting that discussed items associated with me and my position.”
City Councilman Jason Williams has also questioned whether Cantrell’s call with board members violated the open meetings law.
“I definitely don’t agree with that,” Mayor Cantrell said. “I, as mayor, had to take a hard look at that. And once I did, I wanted to inform my board of that. Independent calls. So it was not a meeting. So it was intentional, only to inform. But nothing was voted on. No action was taken.”
This is not the first time Sharon Judkins has left a job under disagreeable circumstances.
She filed a $10.7 million defamation lawsuit after she left a previous job in the city of Richmond, Va. in 2014 where she was deputy chief administrative officer for finance and administration.
A judge has reportedly dismissed her case against the then-city auditor, but the case against the city of Richmond is still listed as active.
Fair Use Notice
This site occasionally reprints copyrighted material, the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We make such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of issues and to highlight the accomplishments of our affiliates. We believe this constitutes a “fair use” of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is available without profit. For more information go to: US CODE: Title 17,107. Limitations on exclusive rights: Fair use. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond “fair use,” you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.